Candour. For the children.

Candour: open, honest, frank, the quality of being honest and telling the truth, especially about a difficult or embarrassing subject. All in all, a good thing.

Openness and honesty are some of the Nolan principles of public life, the ethical standards those working in the public sector are expected to adhere to. Openness and honesty are key values for health and social care in NI. Everyone agrees. No big deal. What are you on about, Speccy?

Imagine this. The worst thing. Your sick child is at the the regional children’s hospital. They may have been sent there from somewhere else, because that’s where the experts are. Something happens and your child dies. Imagine the horror, the grief, the loss.

What if information about your child’s treatment was deliberately withheld from you? What if there was a cover up? What, even, if you discovered that your child’s death was avoidable?

Imagine that your child’s death was avoidable and that the behaviour of individuals contributed to their death. What if the arrangements to ensure quality and the culture of the organisation contributed to the death?

Imagine that very experience happening to other families.

The loved ones of Adam Strain (4), Raychel Ferguson (9), Claire Roberts (9), Conor Mitchell (15), and Lucy Crawford (17 months) don’t have to imagine. Those children died. Their deaths were avoidable. Some of the people involved in their care lied. Rather than tell the families the truth, people acted to protect reputations and avoid blame.

Adam, Raychel, Claire and Conor. Lucy’s family chose not to release a picture.

People who choose to work in health and social care generally do so because they want to help, support and care for others. They don’t set out to be the bad guys, but shit happens. The organisation wins.

Clearly, it’s not just me saying this. Mr Justice O’Hara spent 14 years investigating what happened to the children. It took so long because the health organisations involved were reluctant to release any information. 14 years.

The O’Hara report is a gripping read. Gobsmacking. What happened was truly awful. O’Hara didn’t just tell the tale, he provided 96 recommendations to ensure it couldn’t happen again.

Key recommendations are for a legal Duty of Candour, for both organisations and individuals. O’Hara’s experience taught him that professional ethical guidelines/ standards aren’t always enough to protect patients. That’s why he recommended that it should be a criminal offence to breach that duty.

“All that is required is that people be told honestly what has happened, and a legally enforceable duty of candour for individuals will not threaten those whose conduct is appropriate.”

The Department of Health have been leading preparatory work on the proposed Duty of Candour. Now they want to know what you think. Do let them know.

Do you want medical professionals & organisations to be able to continue to withhold or destroy information, mislead, or lie when something goes wrong. Or do you simply want to know the truth of the thing?

5 thoughts on “Candour. For the children.

  1. You’re so right, when things go wrong we just want to find out why, to help prevent it happening again. Unfortunately people go on the defensive for fear of recriminations, and the truth is hidden for as long as possible.

    1. I agree, they fear the recriminations. It’s difficult because things do go wrong. People are people and they do make mistakes. I think in hospitals (I’ve been in a few) loads of mistakes are made, just because the staff are overworked.
      But the families need the truth. Such a horrendous situation. Because how do you feel when you actually know? It’s like your child’s life was just wasted by someone’s negligence.

  2. One big problem is the blame game – rather than something like truth and reconciliation being part of the culture. I don’t mean forgiving wrongdoing, real carelessness etc, but recognition of how people can be caught in stuff they just don’t handle – like being in an organization where so-called efficiency is just plain exhaustion. the cover-up culture is inexcusable but at the same time understandable, sort of, and once it has started it is hard to stop.

  3. How incredibly sad, for everyone involved. That said, we humans are terribly flawed and, from the top down, have been obfuscating, hedging bets, outright lying for generations, all in the name of self-preservation. Personally, I doubt any amount of legislation, no matter how well-intentioned, will cure that kind of behavior. 😥

  4. How devastating for these families to be the center of such a probe and to wait so long for the truth to be made public. I’m impressed that legislation is being considered, and sad that it would be necessary. Truth is such a slippery commodity these days, and it is bought and sold by power brokers all along the spectrum. These are precious children that were lost, and I’m sure medical ethics are breached everywhere. For those of us fortunate enough to not have experienced the devastating loss of a child, we really cannot imagine, under any circumstances.

what do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s